Absolutely! Many customers pick up their cake the day before their celebration. The best storage method depends on the type of cake you’ve ordered, and we’ll provide instructions specific to your cake when you pick it up.
Traditional buttercream cakes may be stored overnight at room temperature or in the refrigerator. For the best flavor and texture, we recommend allowing buttercream cakes to come completely to room temperature before serving.
Our signature Bavarian Cream Cheesecakes are different. Because they’re frozen as part of the cake-making process, we recommend keeping them in the freezer whenever possible until the day of your event. If freezer space isn’t available, refrigeration is perfectly acceptable, although some condensation may develop on the outside of the cake.
💡 Helpful Tip
Before picking up your cake, make sure you have enough refrigerator or freezer space available—especially for larger cakes.
⭐ Good to Know
When you pick up your cake, we’ll provide personalized storage and thawing instructions based on your cake size and your planned serving time.